UPS delivery error: EEL-1/HUWE1 mutation results in proteasomal dysfunction

From the Lehrbach Lab, Basic Sciences Division

Destruction is as important as creation for a healthy life.

Enter the UPS: the ubiquitin proteasome system. The UPS is a precise way of targeting proteins for destruction, and it is absolutely essential for cell viability and overall organism health.

That doesn’t mean it's a simple system; in fact, the opposite is true. The UPS works through the concerted action of many ubiquitin ligases that attach small proteins called ubiquitin (Ub) to lysines on the target headed for destruction. A single ubiquitin tag is not enough, though. Proteins need long chains of ubiquitins before the proteasome, the cell's protein shredder, will destroy them.

Because the proteasome is so crucial to life, animals encode multiple proteins that can perform these functions. The result is impressive redundancy in the UPS such that mutation or loss of one gene, while stressful to the overall system, is not completely toxic to the animal.

The lab of Dr. Nicolas Lehrbach in the Basic Sciences Division is fascinated by how the UPS is regulated—and how health is impacted when the UPS is dysregulated.

"Failure of protein degradation pathways is thought to contribute to age-dependent decline in health and is often observed in age-dependent neurodegenerative diseases," explains Dr. Lehrbach. 

His lab recently published a study in PLoS Genetics that developed genetic screening to find important proteasomal components in the microscopic roundworm C. elegans. Their findings shed light on the functions of one ubiquitin ligase that plays a conserved role in organisms from yeast to worms to humans.

The authors used an elegant model to screen for proteasome dysfunction. The worm strain used in the screen expresses Ub-tagged GFP: in healthy worms with no proteasomal disruptions, GFP is rapidly degraded.

The authors induced baseline UPS stress through deletion of a crucial proteasomal transcription factor, which decreased the overall lifespan of the animals and made them susceptible to further perturbations to the system. Importantly, these UPS-disrupted animals have low levels of GFP signal, showing that their proteasome continues due to the activity of redundant UPS components.

This baseline proteasomal disruption allows the authors to perform genetic screens for additional proteins involved in proteasome regulation. Knockout of any other components exacerbates the UPS disfunction and causes GFP pile up, resulting in bright green worms.

One hit from this screen is a protein called EEL-1, which is similar to the human gene HUWE1. Variations in HUWE1 are linked to several health issues.

Demonstration of GFP accumulation in worms.
Ubiquitin-tagged GFP allows investigation into the redundant pathways of ubiquitin proteasome regulation. WT background C. elegans don’t show GFP pileup when only one UPS regulator is knocked out (eg: skn-1a in the top row, right column or eel-1 in the bottom two rows, left column). Double knockout of multiple regulators results in bright green worms. Image adapted from original study.

"Mutations in the HUWE1 gene cause a severe neurodevelopmental syndrome," says Dr. Lehrbach. Furthermore, "HUWE1 is often highly expressed and/or mutated in cancer."

He continues, "The underlying reasons why HUWE1 mutations severely affect the nervous system and impact tumorigenesis are not well understood. There are no treatments for the HUWE1 syndrome."

Knockout of eel-1 in wild-type C. elegans did not lead to detectable GFP accumulation. However, combining eel-1 knockout with perturbations of other known proteasome components led to GFP pileup and severe developmental and physiological defects in the worms.

The authors went further: they restored EEL-1 expression, but with mutations in its ubiquitin-binding domains that are homologous to disease alleles in humans with HUWE1-related disorders. These worms also showed severe defects akin to eel-1 knockout, indicating that the ubiquitin ligase activity of the EEL-1 protein is critical for its role in maintaining the UPS.

One striking feature of EEL-1, and other ubiquitin ligases, is the presence of lysine deserts, which are long stretches of amino acids that contain absolutely no lysine residues.

Lysine deserts are thought to be important for regulation of UPS components. Ubiquitin ligases target lysines specifically; therefore, any nearby lysine residues of the ubiquitin ligase itself could lead to auto-ubiquitination and degradation of the ligase instead of the target protein.

To test this hypothesis, the authors engineered lysines into and adjacent to the lysine deserts of EEL-1. They found that, indeed, lysine residues around these critical regions impair EEL-1 stability and ability to ubiquitinate its substrates.

"Our genetic analysis in the worm shows that EEL-1/HUWE1 plays a general role in promoting efficient degradation of ubiquitinated proteins during animal development," says Dr. Lehrbach. "These insights from worm genetics provide a new way to think about HUWE1 functions in human health and disease."

"It suggests," he adds, "that inefficient protein degradation may be an underlying cause of neurodevelopmental symptoms in HUWE1 patients, or the role of HUWE1 in cancer."

In future work, the lab is interested in untangling the complex knot of redundancy in UPS components. HUWE1 is just one of several ubiquitin ligases that promotes efficient protein degradation, and there are many others that could act in tandem in different contexts.

"We are interested in the possibility that a system made up by HUWE1 and other ubiquitin ligases provides animal cells with a versatile way to adapt protein degradation to different types of physiological or environmental stress," Dr. Lehrbach explains. "This is an idea we are actively following up on now."

Additionally, they are interested in whether HUWE1 activity could be enhanced somehow, with the goal of preventing neurodegenerative diseases or enhancing lifespan. The worm's short life makes it ideal for this kind of question, as Dr. Lehrbach explains.

"The worm is a fantastic model to explore the role of HUWE1 in aging,” he says. “Because of its rapid life cycle, experiments that test changes in aging caused by different mutations or drugs can be completed in 3-4 weeks.

“The same experiment in a mouse model would take years!” he emphasizes.

Their system is an impressive and useful model when it comes to detangling our complex system of controlled cellular destruction, and their results could shed light on how to treat diseases caused by the UPS gone haywire.


The spotlighted research was funded by the National Institutes of Health, the National Institute of General Medical Sciences, and the National Institute on Aging.

Fred Hutch/University of Washington/Seattle Children’s Cancer Consortium Member Dr. Nicolas Lehrbach contributed to this research.

Yanagi KS, Chen BJ, Kunjo SO, Topalidou I, Lehrbach N. 2026. Lysine deficiency within a conserved lysine desert is critical for EEL-1/HUWE1 to support ubiquitin proteasome system function. PLoS Genet. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1012273.

Hannah Lewis

Hannah Lewis is a postdoctoral research fellow with Jim Boonyaratanakornkit’s group in the Vaccine and Infectious Disease Division (VIDD). She is developing screens to find rare B cells that produce protective antibodies against human herpesviruses. She obtained her PhD in molecular and cellular biology from the University of Washington.